Here is a collection of "throwback" templates that I designed way back in 2013/2014. I guarantee that each and every one of these is deserving of an award.
Note that some of the background images were not around when I took the screenshots... I had not learned that hotlinking from Google images wasn't best practice yet. The fonts didn't load either, so enjoy Times New Roman.
Note the incredibly funny joke included in that last navbar: "Buy this template"!
This next one isn't terrible, and is actually the first public site I had hosted (on terrible free-tier hosting). It basically just hosted a custom Google search that aggreggated a bunch of different Minecraft server list sites.